Man Calls Murder 'Really Fun'
On September 18, 2025, a chilling act of vigilante justice unfolded in Fremont, California, leaving a community grappling with shock and questions about morality and law. Varun Suresh, a 29-year-old man, allegedly hunted down and murdered 71-year-old David Brimmer, a registered sex offender, in a brutal and premeditated stabbing attack. What makes this case particularly unsettling is not just the violence but Suresh's reported reaction after his arrest — according to a probable cause affidavit obtained by PEOPLE, he told investigators that the killing was "honestly really fun" and justified his actions by saying pedophiles "deserve to die."
The Hunt Begins: A Calculated Attack
According to the Fremont Police Department, officers responded to a 911 call reporting a violent fight between two men in the 600 block of Upper Vinters Circle. Upon arrival, they found Brimmer lying unresponsive on the ground, suffering from severe stab wounds. Despite immediate trauma care, Brimmer reportedly died at the scene.
What sets this case apart is the chilling premeditation behind the attack. Suresh allegedly discovered Brimmer's name, photo, and address on California's public sex offender registry, a website designed to inform the community about convicted offenders. According to the affidavit, he selected Brimmer because of his age, believing the 71-year-old would be "easy to kill," as reported by PEOPLE.
Suresh's method was calculated. He reportedly posed as an accountant, going door-to-door in the neighborhood to avoid suspicion before approaching Brimmer's home. After confirming Brimmer's identity, Suresh allegedly launched the attack, stabbing the elderly man repeatedly. Brimmer managed to flee to a neighbor's house, pounding on the garage door for help, but Suresh followed him inside and allegedly continued the assault in the kitchen. The victim eventually collapsed on the front lawn, succumbing to his injuries.
A Disturbing Mindset: No Regret, Only Justification
What is perhaps most disturbing about this case is Suresh's attitude after the attack. He remained at the scene and spoke to officers, reportedly expressing no remorse. Instead, he justified his actions by stating that pedophiles deserve to die, reflecting a vigilante mindset fueled by a desire for retribution rather than justice through legal means.
According to court documents and police statements, Suresh also told police that he had wanted to kill a sex offender "for years," because "they hurt children" and "deserve to die", as reported by the Times of India.
Investigators say he admitted to searching the Megan's Law website, which lists registered sex offenders, and took screenshots of offenders' details shortly before the killing. His fixation on punishing sex offenders was clear, underscoring a dangerous mix of personal vendetta and violent action.
Legal History of the Victim
David Brimmer's criminal history adds context to the case. According to a Los Angeles Times report cited by PEOPLE, he was charged in 1992 with multiple counts of lewd and lascivious behavior involving minor boys. Brimmer was convicted in 1995 of these offenses and served nine years in prison, as reported by the Times of India.
Charges and Prior Arrests
Suresh now faces multiple charges, including murder, residential burglary, and armed individual causing great bodily injury. According to the Times of India, authorities have also noted a prior arrest in 2021, when Suresh allegedly made a false bomb threat and claimed he was "hunting" the CEO of Hyatt Hotels, whom he believed to be a pedophile. This detail suggests a pattern of behavior driven by a vigilante mindset and possible mental health issues.
The Legal and Social Implications
The case raises complex questions about the role of public sex offender registries. While these registries aim to protect communities by providing transparency, they can also become tools for individuals like Suresh to take the law into their own hands. The community's reaction has been mixed, with some expressing sympathy for Suresh's motives but others warning against vigilante justice and emphasizing the importance of mental health support and legal due process.
Looking Ahead
Varun Suresh is currently in custody and, per court records, will undergo a psychiatric evaluation as part of the legal process, PEOPLE reports. His case will likely spark ongoing debates about the balance between public safety, mental health, and the limits of vigilantism.
In the end, this case is a sobering example of how deeply personal beliefs can lead to devastating consequences when acted upon without restraint or regard for the law. It challenges us all to think critically about justice, accountability, and the ways we protect one another in our communities.
References: Man Stabs Sex Offender, 71, to Death, Says It 'Was Really Fun': Docs | 'Posed as an accountant': How Indian-origin man Varun Suresh plotted paedophile's murder in US; what he told court - The Times of India | Man facing murder charge for killing man he found on sex offender registry, police say
